The stipulation was that the player could not play more than three full seasons with the team. I also did not include Roger Clemens or Dave Winfield as they were two unforgettable on the team in their very short stints.
Catcher – Bengie Molina (2006)
Best Season: 2006 – 20 doubles, 19 home runs, 57 RBI, .281 AVG and .319 OBA
After the 2005 season where the Blue Jays finished two games below .500 they were looking to upgrade on the catching position. They had had one good catcher in Gregg Zaun, however they cycled through four other catchers during the season.