It's been a long time coming.
As always, the grades (and the justifications thereof) are extracted from my nether parts.
A - Outstanding
B - Good
C - Average
D - Below Average (Replacement Level, more or less)
E - Fail
F - Epic Fail
John Gibbons A
Alex Anthopoulos B+
Rogers Communications B
Josh Donaldson A+
Obviously the team's best player. This might have been the greatest season ever by a Blue Jays player - I like it better than Olerud's 1993 season or Delgado's 2003 season, which only leaves Bautista's performance in 2011. His season reminds me a little of when Molitor came here in 1993.