Lucas Duda started the rally with a one-out double off Bush and was replaced by pinch-runner Matt Reynolds. Bush struck out Wilmer Flores for the second out, then walked Curtis Granderson.
Jose Reyes followed with a soft line drive up the middle that second baseman Rougned Odor grabbed on one hop on the outfield grass going to his right. He went to second for the force but bounced his throw.
Shortstop Elvis Andrus appeared to handle it, then dropped the ball and Granderson was ruled safe.