That’s right, this is a defense of Mike Matheny. But before you dismiss this piece, hear me out. I assert that the criticism of Mike Matheny has evolved into a ‘echo chamber.’ Therefore, a complete and fair evaluation of the St. Louis Cardinals manager by fans isn’t being considered.
Matheny’s six-year-plus record in St. Louis is 544-428 (.560), with four playoff appearances, one NL Pennant, and three Central Division Championships. Historically speaking, this compares very well to other Cardinal managers of the past.
Nevertheless, St. Louis Cardinals managers of the past have not be subjected to the same criticisms that Matheny has faced after missing the postseason two years in a row.