It all boiled down to two St. Louis natives again: Ben Bishop and Pat Maroon. And again, like it was in game three, Pat Maroon emerged triumphant. The Blues needed six and a half minutes to get a Vince Dunn shot past Ben Bishop, and the Stars needed two and a half minutes more to get a Mats Zuccarello shot past Jordan Binnington.
For the next three and a half periods, the score would sit at 1-1. By the end of overtime, Ben Bishop would stop 52 of 54 shots on goal (and Binnington would stop 29 of 30), but all it takes is one shot, and that shot came from Rob Thomas.