HARTFORD, Conn. — When SMU’s Ben Emelogu hit a 35-footer at the halftime buzzer of Sunday’s championship game against Cincinnati, the expression on the faces of both Mustangs and Bearcats fans read the same:
“What is going on right now?”
Some were visibly elated, others seemed very confused. Neither team was following the script. The American Athletic Conference Tournament final was supposed to be a brawl. We were promised “Armageddon, Part 3.”
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4cc01/4cc012637596276f33c4ccc3474a300a2a992370" alt="SMU AAC champs Ojeleye embed.jpg"
Instead, No. 12 SMU led Cincinnati by nine. Eight minutes into the second half, the Mustangs had extended that lead to 17.