Who is the greatest of all time? Whenever these types of conversations come up, they always get bogged down by bias, opinion, and different eras being defined by different things, especially in the world of soccer. Pelé was doing moves most replacement level defenders are doing now. Cruyff was running at pudgy defenders. You can make an argument for or against just about anything these days and people will disagree with you. There’s probably a video on YouTube that has millions of views explaining why the Earth is flat, or something.
Not very often is something unanimously agreed upon.