There’s a difference between what a Super Bowl team “looks like” and what a Super Bowl team actually is. The two concepts in a Venn diagram probably share very little of the same surface area. In our minds, a Super Bowl champion is perfect, flawless, dominant. Think of it like the girl or guy of your dreams before you met the real girl or guy of your dreams.
I doubt the reality lined up with your expectations of what you thought that person may look like, sound like, and do for a living — but did it matter?