The 32-year-old escaped the first frame unscathed despite surrendering a walk and a single, but he looked just as shaky in the second, allowing a leadoff double to Brandon Moss and a sharp single to Zach Walters to bring home the game's first run. Michael Brantley and Ryan Raburn both reached with nobody out in the third, and Moss followed a Yan Gomes strikeout with a broken-bat bloop into shallow center field to chase Happ.
A batter later, Giovanny Urshela recorded his first Major League hit and RBI off reliever Tom Wilhelmsen, and Moss scored on Roberto Perez's two-run single to finalize Happ's line.