Well, I'm going to keep this one short in sweet. Both because I've had some computer issues and the one I'm currently using is from the early 2000's (and performs like it), but also because we kind of all know what it's going to come down to: Madison Bumgarner and Noah Syndergaard.
First off, both pitchers going have had very strong seasons, as we know by watching MadBum all year what he's been up to, but young Noah Syndergaard has matched him nearly number for number despite the amount of innings pitched. Sydergaard strikes out a ton of batters, doesn't walk many and doesn't give up the long ball, mostly because he brings a nasty sinker that can hit the upper-90's when he's on along with an array of other above average pitches.