C: Gary Sanchez (Yankees' No. 5 prospect)
Sanchez opened the Fall League on a tear and hit .295/.357/.625 with a league-best seven home runs and 55 total bases in 22 games for Surprise. The 22-year-old showcased his two loudest tools in the Fall Stars Game as he clubbed a two-run home run and threw out a basestealer en route to being named Player of the Game. Sanchez's shortcomings as a blocker and receiver continue to hurt his chances of becoming an everyday catcher, but his cannon of an arm and sound catch-and-throw skills will always allow him to compensate for some of those deficiencies.