If there was any contact at all it was slight. It may well have been outside the box. Actually, it looked as though Alan Smith had tripped himself up.
But referee Alan Wiley pointed to the penalty spot and flashed a red card at Daniel Van Buyten. Leeds United, so desperately in need of some good fortune, weren't about to complain.
Mark Viduka stuck away the penalty and Leeds led Manchester City 2-1 with just 14 minutes remaining. The roar of the Elland Road crowd got them over the line.
Alan Smith tumbles under the challenge of Daniel Van Buyten to win a late Leeds penalty
Leeds were off the bottom of the FA Barclaycard Premiership, two points from safety with nine games to play.