I don’t think there ever has been or ever will be a universal consensus evaluation on a draft pick. Remember, there was a legitimate conversation in the Spring of 1998 over whether Ryan Leaf should be the first-overall pick over Peyton Manning.
In other words, if you look hard enough, you can probably find a scouting report on a player that fits your biases, no matter how greatly it deviates from the majority opinion. We’ve seen contrasting takes, for example, on Chase Claypool, the Pittsburgh Steelers’ top pick this year.