When the Pittsburgh Steelers were at the height of their recent success in the mid-2000s, we probably convinced ourselves that the roster was a lot more future Hall of Fame players than will actually be the case.
While a guy like Jerome Bettis is already in there, and Troy Polamalu is a given, others like James Harrison and Hines Ward may always be on the outside looking in. Others for the Hall of Very Good would include Aaron Smith, Ryan Clark, James Farrior, and Heath Miller.