The Major League Baseball Hall of Fame is nice. Too neat and clean, though. Baseball history also has facets that are delightfully vile, grotesque, and absurd. Let's give it a home. And put real people in charge, like John Waters.
In a recent post, there was an excellent Lonnie Smith thread instigated by The Ghost of Manny Trillo that made me want to have a home for really good players who are maybe not regular Hall of Fame material -- the "Hall of Good" is something we often think of. But I thought about it more, and there are players who deserve their own place who either don't fit in the HoF (or a generic HoG) but who deserve attention for either their unusual lifestyles, paths, or events.