I considered picking Ashton Jeanty, because picking a top-5 RB worked out so well for the Giants last time.
In actuality, this is an interesting position as the fake Giants GM, because the real Giants GM has a far different motivation. It doesn’t take a genius to know that none of none of the 36-year old Russell Wilson, interception-prone journeyman Jameis Winston, or 2023 Bud Light Celebration of the Year winner Tommy DeVito is the long-term answer. However, the GM and coach are both clearly on the hot seat. Signing Russell Wilson is, in my view, an attempt to eek out something like a 7-10 or 8-9 season and preserve their jobs.