Despite Orlando City having a rough season as a whole, Joe Bendik and Cristian Higuita have slowly been moving towards leading in appearances for Orlando City. Both are just outside of the top five, trailing the likes of Kevin Molino and Dennis Chin. Below are the total rankings of appearances for Orlando City (USL and MLS combined).
- Kevin Molino: 144 total appearances with 126 starts.
- Dennis Chin: 103 total appearances with 47 starts.
- Miguel Gallardo: 96 total appearances, starting in all of them.
- Cristian Higuita: 94 total appearances with 79 starts.