But things are different now. Naeher made a save -- a big save -- to send the United States to a World Cup final against Netherlands.
The top 10 trending Twitter topics in the U.S. during the match included "Alyssa Naeher." And Naeher, not goalscorers Morgan and Christen Press, dominated headlines in the days following the game.
After constant criticism and questions about her confidence and ability in big moments, Naeher proved herself. But her reaction after the match wasn't one of validation. Instead, she presented the same calm, focused expression she has every day since the tournament began.