Carrie Lawrence initially joined the Orlando Pride in 2019 as a training player. The University of Central Florida graduate then signed a short-term contract with the team for the 2020 NWSL Fall Series but didn’t appear. She signed her first full-season contract with the Pride in January 2021 on a one-year deal with a team option, making the 2022 NWSL season her second full year with the club.
Lawrence was a regular starter under former coach Amanda Cromwell at the beginning of the season but suffered a rib injury that saw her miss four games.