The argument that we've had for a long time, ever since Ohio State established what I think we can mostly agree is a veritable Pax Columbus over the Big Ten, is whether that kind of dominance is good or bad for Buckeye football.
And I guess what you need to consider if you're going to attempt to answer that question is how much does that dominance impact Ohio State's ability to win national championships, or at least the ability to get the opportunity to win them. After that, you've got to consider the balance required to make the Big Ten competitive, while also gobbling up all the good recruits for yourselves.