This is a tough one, and obviously Beau and I have been ruminating on it for a while now. In our opinion, you can throw out all the arguments about how Brett McMurphy has handled his reporting (not particularly well), or the specific details about whether Zach's citation/arrest/report says X, Y, or Z (he wasn't arrested in 2015), or even the exact chronology of Zach and Courtney Smith's relationship (frankly far too complicated to keep track of).
All that matters for us is how you decide to answer the following two questions:
1. Do you believe that Urban Meyer felt in 2015 (or before) that Zach Smith was a potential abuser of women?