First off, let me say that I fall in the camp that believes Bob Melvin generally manages the bullpen well. That thought is underscored by the fact that I will spend the first part of this post pointing out the many ways in which last night’s meltdown was not the result of poor tactical moves.
Mostly, the A’s snatched defeat from the jaws of victory because one of their better relievers, Joaquim Soria, simply pitched terribly. I don’t even think Soria was left in too long, as all the damage occurred within 5 pitches and I would not suggest yanking your top relievers every time they give up a couple hits to start an inning.