Considering he holds multiple NFL records, it should be no surprise Peyton Manning has a spot on the list.
Manning posted five seasons of 19-plus fantasy points per game, maxing out at 25.6 in 2013. That year, he set NFL standards with 5,477 yards and 55 touchdowns while guiding the Denver Broncos to an AFC title and Super Bowl appearance.
The Indianapolis Colts legend had a steady career for his fake general managers. He averaged 15-plus fantasy points in every season from 2000 to 2014 aside from the 2011 campaign he missed with a neck injury.