The story of Eli Manning's career can't be rewritten at this point. Manning is 35. He will be remembered as an inconsistent regular-season starter who got hot at the right time... twice. He could be a Hall of Famer once he retires, but he will be a borderline case.
Over the last two years, we have gotten a glimpse of what Manning could have been. The Giants quarterback has thrown 65 touchdowns (only Aaron Rodgers and Tom Brady have thrown more) with 8,842 yards, the sixth-most over that span. That production hasn't come with a cost in turnovers either.