The Yankees have been publicly supportive of DJ LeMahieu’s potential bounce-back in 2025, but behind the scenes, there’s reason to believe they’re far less optimistic. According to Bob Klapisch of NJ.com, the organization isn’t fully convinced that LeMahieu can still be an impact player.
“Turner ended up signing with the Cubs on Thursday, meaning the Yankees are stuck with DJ LeMahieu for now. But stay tuned. The Bombers aren’t entirely sold on the idea that LeMahieu can still help.”
A Sharp Decline Over the Past Two Seasons
LeMahieu, now 36, is well past his prime and has been a below-average hitter for two consecutive seasons.