The Yankees drew first blood when Brett Gardner doubled in his first at-bat, moved to third on a Chase Headley groundout, and came home on an Alex Rodriguez sac fly. They then scored another run in the second on a leadoff homer into the second deck by Garrett Jones. However Philadelphia answered in the top of the third when Cesar Hernandez doubled in the speedy Ben Revere. Chris Young took a very awkward route to Hernandez's ball and it might have been catchable had he played it correctly.