Left field has been a question mark for the Yankees for some time now, but between the 2022 and ‘23 seasons, it seemed as though it was answered, somewhat surprisingly, by Oswaldo Cabrera. He was very solid in his 44 games last season, and reinforced it with an excellent spring training this year — he seemed like a guy. But, despite winning the job, the switch-hitter underperformed by a longshot, and was one of the bigger disappointments in a lineup featuring more than one of them.
Grade: F
2023 Statistics: 115 games, 330 plate appearances, .