Yes, Jeter’s final game was technically at Fenway Park on September 28, 2014. However, no one is going to remember that years from now. What people will remember is Jeter’s walk-off hit against the Orioles three days earlier.
The vast majority of people don’t get that ending. A lot of legends and Hall of Famers don’t even get a moment along those lines. Babe Ruth is the greatest player in Yankees’ history, and his final game was in May, while a member of neither of the teams he is famous for playing for.
Many notable Yankees have not gotten the storybook ending.