With all due respect to Miguel Andujar, who’s been my dude since he was in Single-A ball, Gleyber Torres was the best rookie on the 2018 Yankees. Gleyber has Andujar beat in OBP (.340 vs. .328) and he hit three fewer homers and drew 17 more walks in 122 fewer plate appearances. The Baseball Reference version of WAR favors Torres over Andujar (+2.9 vs. +2.2) despite the playing disparity.
Ultimately, it doesn’t matter who’s better. Torres and Andujar are both Yankees and they’re both awesome. The team gets to move forward with both players and that’s pretty cool.