I am someone who is optimistic that Jay Bruce can contribute some value offensively, but that’s no guarantee. In the last three seasons, he’s posted a mere 92 wRC+ and .305 wOBA, meaning he’s no sure thing at all. He’s a power bat and seeing a left-handed hitter is refreshing but is he the best option at 1B?
I think there’s a very compelling case that Mike Tauchman could be a better fit than Bruce in this role. Luke Voit being injured sucks, but if the Yankees are going to capitalize on an opportunity to get creative, why not?