Back to the New York Yankees Newsfeed

One-game wild-card playoff format in baseball is dramatic, but unfair

Neil Best

Neil Best first worked at Newsday in 1982, then returned in 1985. His SportsWatch column debuted on Sept.

The one-game, winner-take-all, wild-card playoff format is four years old now, but this is the first time it has involved a New York team.

Meaning, of course, this is the first time the subject and the debate that surrounds it truly matter.

About that: Is this fair? In a word: not really. OK, that's two words. But a simple "no" doesn't quite cover it.

This system certainly is fairer than the old one, in which second-place teams with good records did not much care about winning division championships because doing so wasn't much of an advantage.