As Aaron Judge came to the plate in the bottom of the fifth with DJ LeMahieu and Gio Urshela on the corners, a wild pitch from Toronto pitcher Marcus Stroman sent Urshela racing toward home plate. Blue Jays catcher Danny Jansen scrambled for the ball and reached too high on Urshela, who extended his left leg in attempt to beat the tag.
Home plate umpire Ryan Blakney called Urshela out.
But Aaron Boone knew he was safe. Judge and Urshela knew it, too.
The Yankees challenged the play and it was quickly overturned, giving them a 3-2 lead just after the Blue Jays had tied it in the top half of the inning.