Since Major League Baseball introduced the Wild Card in 1994, the New York Yankees stand out as the most successful by a wide margin. While fans of the Yankees are no doubt disappointed that they fell short against the Red Sox in the 2018 ALDS, this should not diminish the domination they have shown over the time.
Best by far in the Wild Card era
This season the Yankees made their 20th postseason appearance since the Wild Card was introduced. No other organization has made more than 16 postseason appearances over the same span. They have advanced to the ALCS 11 times.