Big Blue View · Aug 25, 2019
Why has Giants’ QB Eli Manning always been such a divisive player?
Eli Manning Photo by Michael Hickey/Getty Images As he enters his 16th — and probably final — season as the starting quarterback for the New York Giants we are in the same place we have always been with Manning.
We’re arguing about him.
These days there are three questions that are central to the Manning debate:
Why is he still the Giants’ quarterback?
Is he or is he not still an effective starting-caliber NFL quarterback?
There is really one more question that has always been, and remains, central to the Manning debate. Why is it that Manning, a bland personality who has represented the franchise with class since 2004, has always been such a divisive figure?
