With the 2025 NFL Draft fast approaching, the Giants have a clear-cut decision to make: sign a veteran quarterback on a short-term deal while preparing to transition to a rookie.
Trading for an expensive veteran like Derek Carr or Matthew Stafford would create unnecessary financial complications when they could simply sign a free agent for a one-year stopgap. The key is finding the right balance between affordability, experience, and a willingness to mentor a young quarterback.
Why a Trade Makes No Sense
Stafford and Carr both come with hefty price tags. If the Giants were to acquire either, they’d be taking on a significant financial commitment, limiting their ability to build around their future quarterback.