Vincent writes: Here in South Jersey, a doughnuts-and-coffee chain offers a promotion. On the day after a Philadelphia Eagles win, customers get a free iced coffee. My wife, a New York Giants fan, will often collect a free coffee, even though she roots against the Eagles. Please bar her from partaking of coffee the Eagles have earned for their fans.
On the one hand, your wife is free to take advantage of any promotion. And if I guess the doughnuts-and-coffee chain correctly, coffee from them is punishment enough. On the other hand, while this court is largely indifferent to sports, it does appreciate the concept of fair play.