With the bumbling New York Giants on their bye week, this is a good time to go through a position-by-position assessment of the roster. Where have they been good? Where have they been bad? Where do they obviously need help going into 2025?
Some of the answers to where they need help going forward are obvious. Quarterback, defensive line, cornerback, youth on the offensive line roll off the fingertips.
I don’t want this to be a high-level exercise, though. I am often asked to assess Joe Schoen’s job as general manager. We now have three years of evidence with which to try and answer the question “What kind of job has Schoen done as Giants GM?