DE Jason Pierre-Paul
Pierre-Paul should be the Giants' top priority. He was having a Pro Bowl-caliber season before suffering a core injury in Week 13. That injury shouldn't have any long-term effects and the 28-year-old answered any questions about his ability to play at a high level after the fireworks accident that mangled his right hand before the 2015 season. The Giants don't have anyone capable of filling Pierre-Paul's role as an all-around defensive end if he leaves. While there will be a tipping point if another team offers a ludicrous contract, the Giants should be prepared to pony up to keep Pierre-Paul.