New York City Starting XI (3-4-3, L-to-R): Johnson; Matarrita, Callens, Ibeagha; Herrera, Ofori, Ring, Moralez; Berget, Villa, Tajouri-Shradi
Bench: Stuver; Hountondji, Tinnerholm, Sweat, McNamara, Medina, Wallace
- Suspended: None
- Suspended after next caution: MF Alexander Ring, MF Yangel Herrera
- Injury: QUESTIONABLE: D - Maxime Chanot (undisclosed injury)
Colorado Rapids Starting XI (3-5-2, L-to-R): Howard (c); Smith, Wilson, Wynne; Castillo, Nicholson, Azira, Boateng, Martinez; Mason, Badji
Bench: Boli, Colvey, Gashi, MacMath, McBean, Serna, Sjöberg
- Suspended: None
- Suspended after next caution: F Dominique Badji
- Injury: OUT: D - Kortne Ford (left MCL sprain), D - Marlon Hairston (right knee surgery)
Referees: Christopher Penso (referee); Jeremy Hanson, Nick Uranga (assistant referees); Baldomero Toledo (4th official); Kevin Terry, Jr.