The question is not whether Giannis deserves to be an All-Star. The question is whether he deserves to start as an All-Star.
This is where we are one month into the season. To emphasize, we are just one month into the season, but Giannis has been playing at a star level since last February (after the last All-Star Game). So the Bucks are on a path to have their first All-Star since Michael Redd in 2004. To put that in perspective, the team’s current head coach made five All-Star appearances as a player since the last Bucks player made it.