This one was a nail-biter. Easily the closest voting results for the 2015 season, with five different pitchers earning at least one first place vote.
Jimmy Nelson Total Votes: 23 First Place: 3
Francisco Rodriguez Total Votes: 19 First Place: 3
Taylor Jungmann Total Votes: 18 First Place: 1
Mike Fiers Total Votes: 9 First Place: 1
Will Smith Total Votes: 6 First Place: 1
Jeremy Jeffress Total Votes: 3 First Place: 0
An interesting thing happened in this voting season. The runner-up, K-Rod, was left off of the ballot (top 3) by four different current or former writers and editors.