After winning the opener against the Mets, the Brewers entered game two hoping to continue their recent winning ways. Julio Teheran took the mound for the Brewers while David Peterson was on the mound for New York. Both pitchers were dealing through the first three innings until Teheran got into trouble in the bottom of the fourth.
Brandon Nimmo led off with a solo home run, and one out later, Francisco Lindor hit a solo home run, giving the Mets a two-run advantage. Teheran would get in trouble again in the bottom of the fifth inning, when Nimmo homered again, this time bringing Vogelbach home as well, and the Mets led 4-0.