Most quarterbacks probably wouldn’t mind being on a list of the worst Super Bowl-winning quarterbacks because it would mean they own a Super Bowl ring. It’s kind of like being the ugliest Miss America or the flabbiest Mr. Universe.
Only 31 quarterbacks have won Super Bowls. Ten of them are in the Hall of Fame and at least a couple more will follow, perhaps even one or two on this list. This is such an elite group that a quarterback can be among the worst and still be pretty good.
That said, there are some middling quarterbacks who have touched the Lombardi Trophy.