Warning, this may be very painful for some fans. The first one I remember is selecting Jamar Fletcher over Drew Brees. The next one was selecting Eddie Moore over Anquan Boldin. We then took Daunte Culpepper over Drew Brees again.
Let us not forget taking Ronnie Brown over Aaron Rodgers. The trend is that all the names I mentioned that Miami Dolphins choose over guys I really wanted washed out of the NFL with little to no success once they became Dolphins, while the other names that we avoided have great careers and have enjoyed winning Super Bowls with their teams.