Francis Okoronkwo’s powerful 12th minute shot took Everton in front in the evening game, but Travis Binnion’s Reds were quick with their response.
Charlie McNeill dispatched from the spot after Alejandro Garnacho was brought down in the 13th minute, and 15 minutes later a wonderfully-worked move, involving McNeill and Jurado, was headed home by Kobbie Mainoo.
United's dominance grew after the break and Sam Mather extended the side's lead from close range.
Moments before full-tie, Alejandro Garnacho scored a fantastic solo goal on the counter-attack, storming down the left wing before cutting inside to finish past Patrick Nash in the Toffees goal.