Wayne Rooney opened the scoring with a wonderful free-kick on 42 minutes, curling home a delightful effort that beat Artur Boruc in the Hoops net.
But just after the hour mark, the visitors hit back as Gary Hooper tapped home from close range, reacting the quickest to Stiliyan Petrov's long-range effort.
With the game finishing level after 90 minutes, a penalty shootout was played to decide the winner, with Darren O'Dea slotting home the winner as Paul Lambert's Legends emerged the winners.
FIRST HALF
Rooney's return was welcomed with wholesale joy as his name was announced prior to kick-off, with our iconic forward starting alongside Dimitar Berbatov and Antonio Valencia.