The show's host Liam Bradford and guests Ben Thornley, James Ducker and David McDonnell offered their opinions after being presented with the options of Casemiro, Diogo Dalot, Lisandro Martinez and Marcus Rashford, who have all been shortlisted after a hectic run of nine games.
It ended in a split decision with Dalot and Martinez gaining our pundits' recognition for their efforts during a largely positive period for Erik ten Hag's side.
"I'm going to go for an unorthodox one," said former winger Thornley. "I'll say Diogo Dalot."
The Mirror journalist McDonnell agreed with the ex-player, adding: "It's Dalot for me, because he's an unsung hero.