Back to the Manchester United Newsfeed

'He was never going to win them the title!': Jamie Carragher and Roy Keane clash over 'panic signing' Cristiano Ronaldo, the 'madness' of Gary Neville - and why Pep Guardiola could surpass Sir Alex Ferguson to become the best Premier League manager EVER

Cristiano Ronaldo's return to Manchester United has proved a mixed bag, so it was no surprise to see Jamie Carragher and Roy Keane disagree over his impact at Old Trafford this term.

Ronaldo returned to the club last summer to much fanfare 12 years after departing for Real Madrid but ahead of Liverpool and United's clash in the Premier League on Tuesday, Jamie Carragher believes United made a mistake signing the the Portuguese star.

Speaking with Keane in face-to-face discussion from LADBible, Carragher claimed part of the mistake was due to Ronaldo not being enough to push United into a Premier League title fight, with the Red Devils down in fifth this term and 20 points off the summit.