Ten years ago, Manchester City became the first English side to beat Schalke in their own back yard, perhaps extra motivated after the stadium announcer committed the ultimate faux pas of introducing them as Manchester United.
Benjani and Stephen Ireland scored in a 2-0 UEFA Cup group game win back in 2008, Dietmar Hamman was running midfield and a young Manuel Neuer was in goal for the hosts.
With City meeting Schalke in the Champions League last 16, Sportsmail fancied a blast from the past so has taken a look at the line-up from 2008 to see where the players are now.