With one out and the scored tied at 6 in the top of the 10th, Schoop fielded a chopper off the bat of Norichika Aoki and flipped to Simmons, who was covering second. Simmons made the turn and fired to first baseman Curt Smith, where first-base umpire Larry Vanover called Aoki out. Aoki immediately pointed to the bag, as did the first-base coach, claiming Simmons' throw pulled Smith off the bag.
The call stood, despite replay showing the throw did, in fact, pull Smith off the bag.
Instant replay challenges cannot be requested until the final four teams meet at Dodger Stadium.